Sanibel & Captiva Islands FL Realtor
Realtor
Sanibel, FL same city
Pfeifer Realty Group
Photo: Blind Pass, Sanibel and Captiva by Invertzoo, CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons
Real Estate Brokerage in Sanibel
About Pfeifer Realty Group
Pfeifer Realty Group is a real estate brokerage listed in Sanibel, Florida. In its own words, the company calls itself Southwest Florida's most recommended real estate team. Sanibel is a barrier island community known for beaches and a distinct island lifestyle, and the group's work centers on that part of the Gulf Coast.
It is also reasonable to ask who on the team will be your main contact and how showings are handled for buyers who live out of state.
Southwest Florida's Most Recommended Real Estate Team— How Pfeifer Realty Group describes the business
What the data says about Sanibel
Many listings nearby
24 other listed real estate professionals work within 25 miles of Sanibel, 4 of them in Sanibel itself. The map and the list further down sort them by distance.
Location
Sanibel, Florida
Local time
8:19 AMSanibel · Eastern Time · Wednesday, October 14
No published office hours. If this is your listing, you can send your hours.
Home values in Sanibel
Typical home$800K
1-year-1.8%
5-year-13.2%
10-year+15.9%
The typical home in Sanibel was valued at about $800,189 in August 2026, according to the Zillow Home Value Index. Over twelve months the typical value fell 1.8%, against a 1.5% decline for Florida as a whole. Zoom out to five years and values are -13.2%. Sanibel sits 113% above the Florida typical value of $375,470.
Source: Zillow Home Value Index, August 2026. More on the Sanibel market
Profile details
| Name | Pfeifer Realty Group |
|---|---|
| Profile type | Real Estate Brokerage |
| Primary market | Sanibel, Florida |
| County | Lee County |
| Social media followers | 2,502 |
| License regulator | Florida Real Estate Commission (DBPR) |
| Time zone | Eastern Time |
| Last reviewed | October 13, 2026 |
Communities around Sanibel
| Community | Distance | Typical home | 1 year | Listed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fort Myers Beach, FL | 4.5 mi | $486,185 | -0.9% | 2 |
| Cape Coral, FL | 9.1 mi | $335,825 | -3.9% | 7 |
| Estero, FL | 13 mi | $485,717 | -3.5% | 3 |
| Fort Myers, FL | 16 mi | $305,650 | -5.0% | 5 |
| Bonita Springs, FL | 17 mi | $502,803 | -3.2% | 4 |
| Naples, FL | 25 mi | $544,120 | -2.4% | 13 |
| Lehigh Acres, FL | 27 mi | $279,720 | -5.8% | 2 |
| Punta Gorda, FL | 33 mi | $332,696 | -5.2% | 5 |
Questions about Pfeifer Realty Group
Where is Pfeifer Realty Group located?
Pfeifer Realty Group is listed in Sanibel, Florida (Lee County).
Which nearby communities have listed professionals?
Fort Myers Beach (4.5 mi, 2 listings), Cape Coral (9.1 mi, 7 listings), Estero (13 mi, 3 listings), and Fort Myers (16 mi, 4 listings).
What does a typical home cost in Sanibel?
About $800,189 in August 2026 (Zillow Home Value Index), -1.8% versus a year earlier.
Is this your profile?
Send a correction, add office hours or ask us to remove this page. Messages go to the Realtor US editorial team, not to Pfeifer Realty Group.
Other realtors near Sanibel
The 9 closest listings, sorted by distance. Every town's full list is on its city page.
Tiffany & Jeff Burns
Real Estate Team
Sanibel, FL same city
Tina DiCharia
Real Estate Agent · Pfeifer Realty Group
Sanibel, FL same city
Valerie Tutor
Real Estate Agent
Sanibel, FL same city
- Waterfront & Lake Homes
Alex King Group
Real Estate Team · Premiere Plus Realty
Fort Myers Beach, FL 4.5 mi
- Luxury Homes
Jose Echevarria
Real Estate Agent · Keller Williams Fort Myers & The Islands
Fort Myers Beach, FL 4.5 mi
Adrianah Sells Realty
Real Estate Agent
Cape Coral, FL 9.1 mi
Cape Premier Realty
Real Estate Brokerage
Cape Coral, FL 9.1 mi
Diana Rodriguez
Real Estate Agent
Cape Coral, FL 9.1 mi